Back
Home » News
  •  
    Filmi Bollywood
    • Why Katrina Kaif Doesn't Like To Party Hard On Her Birthday
    • Aishwarya Rai Bachchan Goes UNRECOGNIZABLE In New York? Roams Around With Aaradhya & Abhishek [PICS]
    • Happy Hardy And Heer Teaser: Himesh Reshammiya Is Back In A Double Role & We're Speechless!
    • These Unseen Pictures From Pooja Batra-Nawab Shah's Wedding Look Every Bit DREAMY!
    • Netflix Announces Five India Originals – Shahrukh Khan & Anushka Sharma To Produce
    • Super 30 Box Office Fourth Day Collection: Hrithik Roshan's Film Is Steady On Monday
    • This Video Of Priyanka Chopra Singing 'Sucker' In Karaoke Session Is Trending On The Internet!
    • Anushka Sharma Married Virat Kohli At The Age Of 29 Because Of This Reason!
    • Sameera Reddy Shares The First Picture Of Her Newborn: We Prayed For A Baby Girl & We're Blessed
    • Hrithik Roshan's Super 30 Made TAX-FREE In Bihar!
    • Why Kangana Ranaut Is Ceasing To Be The Role Model We Once Admired
    • Tiger Shroff: You Have To Know When To Keep Your Mouth Shut
    • These Pictures Of Katrina Kaif Prove That She Is A Beach Bum!
    • Katrina Kaif On Bollywood: You Need To Have Nerves Of Steel To Be Here; It's An Unpredictable Place
    • VIRAL! Salman Khan's Bottle Cap Challenge Comes With A Twist; See Video Here
    • Shahrukh Khan To Be Honoured With Honorary Doctorate By Melbourne's La Trobe University
SC refuses to stay decision on Maratha quota, says no retrospective effect on decision
Oneindia | 12th Jul, 2019 12:37 PM

New Delhi, July 12: The Supreme Court has refused to stay the decision relating to the Maratha quota. The court said that there will not be a retrospective effect on the Maratha reservation and the reservation would be subject to the outcome of the petitions.

A plea had been filed in the Supreme Court challenging the Bombay High Court order which upheld the constitutional validity of the quota for the Maratha community in education and government jobs in Maharashtra.

The petitioner said the Socially and Educationally Backward Classes (SEBC) Act, which provided a 12-per cent and a 13-per cent quota to the Maratha community in education and jobs respectively, breached the 50-per cent ceiling on reservation fixed by the apex court in its landmark judgment in the Indira Sahwney case, also known as the "Mandal verdict".

Sanjeet Shukla, a representative of "Youth for Equality", an NGO, claimed in the petition that the framing of the SEBC Act for Marathas was done under "political pressure" and in "full defiance" of the constitutional principles of equality and rule of law.

"The high court erred in concluding that the mere fact that other OBCs would have to share their reservation quotas with the Marathas (if the Marathas were simply included in the existing OBC category) constitutes an exceptional circumstance warranting a breach of the 50 per cent ceiling limit set by Indira Sawhney," the plea filed by advocate Pooja Dhar said.

The Bombay High Court, in its June 27 order, said the 50-per cent cap on reservation imposed by the Supreme Court could be exceeded only in exceptional circumstances.

"The majority in the Indira Sawhney case held that the ceiling limit of 50 per cent was a binding rule and not merely a rule of prudence," the plea said.

It said the high court's order upheld a 65-per cent reservation in Maharashtra (there being no community hailing from far-flung or remote areas), which was contrary to the nine-judge bench decision of the Supreme Court in the Indira Sawhney case.

"It is evident that the Maharashtra government has made a mockery of the rule of law. It has also used its constitutional powers arbitrarily and purely for political gains," the plea said.

It said the SEBC Act was "unconstitutional" for violating the Bombay High Court's 2015 order without removing its basis, overstepping the constitutional limitations contained in the 102nd amendment to the Constitution and for merely succumbing to political pressure, in complete violation of the constitutional principles of rule of law.

According to the 102nd amendment to the Constitution, reservation can be granted only if a particular community is named in the list prepared by the president.

The plea further claimed that the Bombay High Court "erred" in concluding that the mere fact that 85 per cent of Maharashtra's population was "backward" was so extraordinary as to warrant a breach of the 50-per cent ceiling limit.

It also claimed that the high court overlooked the fact that Marathas occupied 40 per cent of the government jobs available in the open category.

"The high court overlooked the fact that the Gaikwad Commission itself recorded that the Maratha community forms only 19 per cent of the population, which shows that the assumption behind the SEBC Act that Marathas constitute 30 per cent of the population was bad," it said.

   
 
Health and Life
  • Kunal Khemu's Fitness And Diet Tips
  • Diet For Jaundice: Foods To Eat And Foods To Avoid
  • Multiple Sclerosis: Causes, Symptoms, Diagnosis And Treatment
    • 7 Nutritious Foods That Help Promote Beard Growth
    • Epidermodysplasia Verruciformis (EV): Causes, Symptoms, Diagnosis And Treatment
    • 20 Healthy Snacks To Curb Hunger
      • Sustainable Menstruation Through Menstrual Cup: Keeping You & The Earth Clean
      • What Is Solomon's Seal? Its Benefits, Side Effects And Recipes
      • 8 Amazing Health Benefits Of Rose Hip
        • Anand Kumar Of Super 30 Reveals He Has Acoustic Neuroma - All You Need To Know About This Condition
        • 6 Amazing Benefits Of Ice Cubes For Your Health
        • 7 Fascinating Health Benefits Of Chicory You Must Know!
          • Empty Nose Syndrome: Causes, Symptoms, Diagnosis & Treatment
          • How Diabetes Affects Male Fertility
          • How Does Diabetes Affect Male Fertility
            • Wheezing: Symptoms, Causes And Treatment
            • 10 Natural Remedies To Treat Hypothyroidism
            • Phlebitis: Causes, Symptoms, Diagnosis & Treatment
              • 6 Astonishing Health Benefits Of Mango Leaves
              • 6 Lesser Known Health Benefits Of Tomatillos, Nutrition & Recipe
              • 10 Natural Essential Oils For Back Pain